Gemma and Addison are high school juniors, best friends, and majorettes in the marching band. Max and Carter are best friends too, and they're starters for the football team. When Max and Carter start flirting with Gemma and Addison after football practice, the girls can't believe their luck. But which guy wants which girl? Gemma is into Max, so she's secretly crushed when he asks out Addison—but then Carter asks her out (making for a double date). Better to spend any time with Max than not at all, right? When it starts to seem that Max may have deeper feelings for her, Gemma must decide who is more important: her best friend or her crush?